20182017201620152014
| Boys All American – 2018 | ||
| Player | Team | Position |
| Boys All Academic – 2018 | ||
| Player | School | Position |
| Bob Scott Award – 2018 | ||
| Player | Team | Position |
| Boys All American – 2017 | ||
| Player | Team | Position |
| Boys All Academic – 2017 | ||
| Player | School | Position |
| Bob Scott Award – 2017 | ||
| Player | Team | Position |
| Boys All American – 2016 | ||
| Player | Team | Position |
| Anthony Kennin | Homestead High School | Goalie |
| Jake Keyes | Verona Area High School | Attack |
| Will Kirkpatrick | Arrowhead High School | Midfield |
| Logan Kreinz | Kettle Moraine High School | Midfield |
| Dominic Haight | Catholic Memorial HIgh School | Midfield |
| Jordan Schmid | Kettle Moraine High School | Midfield |
| Boys All Academic – 2016 | ||
| Player | School | Position |
| Riley Collins | Oregon High School | Midfield |
| Conner Finnegan | Edgewood High School | MIdfield |
| Dominic Haight | Catholic Memorial High School | Midfield |
| Nick Scharrer | Catholic Memorial High School | Defense |
| Mitchell Bacon | Middleton HIgh School | Attack |
| Nicholas Tennessen | Brookfield East High School | Midfield |
| Bob Scott Award – 2016 | ||
| Player | Team | Position |
| Dominic Haight | Catholic Memorial High School | Midfield |
| Boys All American – 2015 | ||
| Player | Team | Position |
| Alex Jamieson | Arrowhead High School | Defense |
| Ben Frost | Arrowhead High School | Attack |
| Connor Zilisch | Appleton | Midfield |
| Ethan Arnett | Arrowhead High School | Defense |
| Luke Kazda | Verona Area High School | Attack |
| Luke Thomson | Verona Area High School | LSM |
| Boys All Academic – 2015 | ||
| Player | School | Position |
| Jackson Pundt | Verona Area High School | Midfield |
| Tyler Elliott | Janesville Craig High School | MIdfield |
| Bob Scott Award – 2015 | ||
| Player | Team | Position |
| l | ||
